The coronavirus pandemic wiped out most spring practices and disrupted the rhythm of college football's preseason, with player quarantines, uncertainty about playing games — or both.
It also prompted some coaches to make a decision about how much live blocking and tackling there would be in practices. There was a balance to strike, especially when the date of the first game was a moving target. Mitigating players' risk of infection was always in the back of coaches' minds.
West Virginia's Neal Brown said his concerns were preparing offensive linemen to move opponents off the line of scrimmage and defenders to tackle in open space.
“And that's still my concern," he said, "maybe more so after watching some of the games.”
No opening game illustrated the different practice approaches more than BYU's 55-3 romp over Navy on Monday night.
BYU coach Kalani Sitake put his team through three full-contact scrimmages and other full-pad drills. Navy coach Ken Niumatalolo, wanting to protect his team from COVID-19, had his players hit tackling dummies and blocking bags instead of each other.
The Midshipmen’s triple-option generated just 119 yards rushing. The passing game, used as more of a changeup, was awful. The offensive line allowed five sacks on just 13 pass plays.
According to Pro Football Focus, 172 of BYU’s 301 yards rushing came after contact and 161 of its 279 yards passing came after the catch. PFF counted 14 missed tackles by Navy.
Niumatalolo expressed regret minutes after the game for not allowing live hitting in practice. He told reporters Wednesday he would return to the normal practice regimen.
“Touch football is over,” he said.
North Carolina's Mack Brown said coaches were in a tough position a month ago because it wasn't certain there would be a season.
“So every coach has handled it differently,” Brown said. "I think we’ll see the early games, in some cases, ugly. There’ll be a lot of mistakes. But I think as the coaches get more comfortable and the players get more comfortable moving forward, I think we’ll see the normal game come back before we get to the end of the year.”
Wake Forest coach Dave Clawson began practice Aug. 1 thinking his team would open Aug. 30 against Utah State. The ACC's revised schedule, announced Aug. 6, pushed the Demon Deacons' opener to this Saturday against No. 1 Clemson.
Clawson said he wasn't optimistic there would even be a season until two or three weeks ago.
“I didn’t feel it was right to have our players tackle and go to the ground where there’s a higher risk of injury until I knew with greater certainty that we were going to play,” Clawson said.
Wake Forest usually has two or three scrimmages but this year had “one and a half,” he said.
“We have tackled, but not nearly as much as we usually do," Clawson said. "And I have no regrets doing that, regardless of what happens on Saturday. To me, it was the responsible thing to do."
Army had its usual number of full-contact practices in the preseason — “business as usual,” coach Jeff Monken said — and was sharp in a 42-0 win over Middle Tennessee.
Monken said Army's setup in West Point, New York, alleviated some of the worries about coronavirus transmission. He pointed out all players and coaches live on campus, and goods and services are readily available, making it a quasi-bubble.
Monken said he and his staff needed to evaluate young players, and that couldn't be done adequately without live hitting. He said all the usual coronavirus precautions were taken.
“But we wanted to play football, so we approached camp really like we would any other preseason camp,” Monken said. “And we're fortunate to be here in this environment. We've been able to maintain this bubble, which is really unique, and we've been able to stay healthy and have a normal preseason camp."
Practices proceeded normally at Clemson. Tigers coach Dabo Swinney said more conditioning work was done early because the pandemic pushed back the start of the season, but when it was time for contact, there was contact.
“As far as how we practice, how we prepare," Swinney said, "nothing changed in that regard.”
AP Sports Writers Aaron Beard, John Raby, Pete Iacobelli, Mark Long and AP College Football Writer Ralph Russo contributed to this report
More AP college football: https://apnews.com/Collegefootball and https://twitter.com/AP_Top25